Comic Transcripts

[[A LADY IN A BERET and her similarly FASHIONABLE FRIEND chat. A BEARDED EAVESDROPPER stands nearby.]]

FASHIONABLE FRIEND: Juliet always goes for no-good men.

LADY IN A BERET: What about Larry? He’s nice enough.

FASHIONABLE FRIEND: He’s the exception that proves the rule!

BEARDED EAVESDROPPER: That doesn’t make sense. Wouldn’t an exception DISPROVE a rule?

[[The ladies don’t seem to hear. The eavesdropper turns to a MONOCLED LINGUIST.]]

BEARDED EAVESDROPPER: If something started FALLING UP, we wouldn’t say, “Oh, the exception proves our notion of gravity is right!” NO! We’d figure out in what way our understanding of gravity was PROVEN INCORRECT.

MONOCLED LINGUIST: The saying isn’t about proving (asserting the truth of) a rule (a guideline). It’s about PROVING (in the sense of honing) a RULE (in the sense of a straightedge).

MONOCLED LINGUIST: So when an exception proves a rule, it DEFINES a FIRM EDGE. It says “Ah! THAT fell outside the bounds of our precept.”

MONOCLED LINGUIST: In your example, figuring out a modified theory of gravity would be the act of PROVING THE RULE.

BEARDED EAVESDROPPER: Wait a second…aren’t you that linguist who always LIES to everyone? Are you lying to me NOW?

MONOCLED LINGUIST: Perhaps this conversation is…THE EXCEPTION THAT PROVES THE RULE.

BEARDED EAVESDROPPER: But which definition? Mine or yours?

MONOCLED LINGUIST: AHAHAHAHAHA!!!!

{{header: prove it at WONDERMARK.COM}}

#920; In which an Exception is made transcribed by in

[[A LADY IN A BERET and her similarly FASHIONABLE FRIEND chat. A BEARDED EAVESDROPPER stands nearby.]]

FASHIONABLE FRIEND: Juliet always goes for no-good men.

LADY IN A BERET: What about Larry? He's nice enough.

FASHIONABLE FRIEND: He's the exception that proves the rule!

BEARDED EAVESDROPPER: That doesn't make sense. Wouldn't an exception DISPROVE a rule?

[[The ladies don't seem to hear. The eavesdropper turns to a MONOCLED LINGUIST.]]

BEARDED EAVESDROPPER: If something started FALLING UP, we wouldn't say, "Oh, the exception proves our notion of gravity is right!" NO! We'd figure out in what way our understanding of gravity was PROVEN INCORRECT.

MONOCLED LINGUIST: The saying isn't about proving (asserting the truth of) a rule (a guideline). It's about PROVING (in the sense of honing) a RULE (in the sense of a straightedge).

MONOCLED LINGUIST: So when an exception proves a rule, it DEFINES a FIRM EDGE. It says "Ah! THAT fell outside the bounds of our precept."

MONOCLED LINGUIST: In your example, figuring out a modified theory of gravity would be the act of PROVING THE RULE.

BEARDED EAVESDROPPER: Wait a second...aren't you that linguist who always LIES to everyone? Are you lying to me NOW?

MONOCLED LINGUIST: Perhaps this conversation is...THE EXCEPTION THAT PROVES THE RULE.

BEARDED EAVESDROPPER: But which definition? Mine or yours?

MONOCLED LINGUIST: AHAHAHAHAHA!!!!

{{header: prove it at WONDERMARK.COM}}

'Prove the rule' actually comes from the idea that a king or queen had the legal right to punish criminal offenders -- thus coming down hard on 'exceptions' to the law was proving the power of their rulership. Either that or it's an obscure ELO lyric that became a proto-meme on Laugh-In.

We have seen the Useless Linguist before.

My newest game: Noodle Battle! At PAX!

The past few weeks have been a frenzy of assembling the very laborious, very bespoke first print run of NOODLE BATTLE, the puzzle game I am releasing this weekend at PAX West in Seattle!

PAX has an event called the PNW Tabletop Game Market (Saturday night ONLY), which is a curated selection of short-run games from local designers. As I’ve mentioned in this space before, I applied for a space in this fall’s event mainly as a way to force myself to finish a new game. And here it is!

The drawings are all by Jason Poland, good pal and cartoonist of My Dad Is Dracula. Jason played an early version of this game at Alaska Robotics Comics Camp this spring, and really liked it!

So I said, “Do you want to help me make it?” And so he has! It was his idea to make all the characters fun little animals, and I think it adds a ton of charm.

Because this edition is limited-run, it has been incredibly labor-intensive to make! The boxes and cards were made by a game factory in the usual fashion, but separately. The blank tiles were made by a woodworker dude out of Connecticut. For each game, we have had to:

  • Cut a piece of plastic and install the box window
  • Paint all the tiles, hundreds at a time
  • Apply a sticker to both sides of every tile
  • Apply stickers to the box (we couldn’t get the box back printed in time, so the whole back side of the box is a sticker too)
  • Apply the “Nutrition Facts” sticker, which was a late suggestion by my kid that I just had to run with
  • Fold up the rule sheet (they come from the printer as big strips of paper)
  • Put all the components into the box and seal it all up

I knew it would be a lot of work and would require some inefficient, expensive compromises AND I WAS RIGHT. But the final product is turning out great, which is the important thing!!

I will have 50 copies with me (if all goes well) at PAX, and then between now and the holidays we will be putting together additional copies to round out this first edition.

I will announce additional copies on Patreon first, once they are available online!! And here too, naturally, before long.

You can also sign up here if you’d like me to email you once the game is available online!


Recent blog posts